Imagine your favorite wrestling couple suddenly hit by scandal—like a romance drama but in a WWE ring. Wrestling veteran Dutch Mantell recently opened up on his podcast, Storytime, suggesting that WWE consider a wild angle: have Scarlett cheat on her real-life husband Karrion Kross to inject real heat into their stories.
Why A Cheating Angle Could Work
Think about it—infidelity plots grab attention. Mantell emphasized that fans can relate: “You’ve got a girlfriend and suddenly she starts liking another guy… that’s controversy.” He even floated the idea of Scarlett dumping Kross—or vice versa—to spark genuine drama. It’s reality-meets-entertainment, where backstage rumors and online gossip come to life in front of 70,000 fans.
Could WWE Go There?
Karrion Kross and Scarlett have been together since debuting in WWE in 2022. Their contracts run out this August, and though extension talks are happening, nothing’s locked in yet . With their real relationship and shared on-screen time, adding a betrayal storyline would be a calculated swerve—and potentially huge ratings bait. It’d be like turning a quiet romance novel into a scandalous thriller.
Risks, Rewards, and Fan Reactions
Would fans buy into Scarlett stepping out? It’s risky. Here’s a table to unpack the pros and cons:
| Angle Variant | Pros | Risks |
|---|---|---|
| Scarlett cheats | Instant shock, headline-making buzz | Backlash if seen as disrespecting real marriage |
| Kross cheats | Flips expectations, builds sympathy for Scarlett | Could look like WWE exploiting real feelings |
| Break-up with no cheating | Emotional separation without scandal | Less sensational—might feel flat |
| No breakup | Keeps couple united, avoids controversy | Might miss opportunity for bigger drama |
The cheating option would explode on social media and news platforms. But misuse could make WWE look like it’s exploiting a real-life marriage, especially with Kross and Scarlett actually married since April 2022.
Conclusion
WWE considers drama a cornerstone of storytelling—but this idea would walk a fine ethical line. Dutch Mantell’s suggestion to add adultery into their on-screen plot could bring intense interest, but it risks crossing personal boundaries. If WWE proceeds with it, they’d have to script with respect, clarity, and consent—because in this case, fiction could hurt real relationships.